Key Difference – Thomson vs Rutherford Model of Atom
The key difference between Thomson and Rutherford model of atom is that Thomson model of atom does not contain any details about nucleus whereas Rutherford model of atom explains about the nucleus of an atom. J.J. Thomson was the first to discover the subatomic particle called electron in 1904. The model he proposed was named as ‘plum pudding model of the atom”. But in 1911, Ernest Rutherford came up with a new model for the atom after his discovery of the atomic nucleus in 1909.
1. Overview and Key Difference
2. What is Thomson Model of Atom
3. What is Rutherford Model of Atom
4. Side by Side Comparison – Thomson vs Rutherford Model of Atom in Tabular Form
What is Thomson Model of Atom?
The Thomson model of atom is called Plum pudding model because it states that the atom looks like a plum pudding. The only known details about the atom at that time were,
- Atoms are composed of electrons
- Electrons are negatively charged particles
- Atoms are neutrally charged
Since electrons are negatively charged, Thomson suggested that there should be a positive charge in order to neutralize the electrical charge of the atom. The Thomson model of atom explains that electrons are embedded in a positively charged solid material which is spherical in shape. This structure looks like a pudding with plums embedded on it and was named as plum pudding model of atom. This proved the assumption that states an atom is neutrally charged since this model states the negative charges of electrons are neutralized by the positive charge of the solid sphere. Although this model proved that atoms are neutrally charged, it was rejected after the discovery of the nucleus.
What is Rutherford Model of Atom?
According to the Rutherford model of atom, the so-called plum pudding model of Thomson was incorrect. Rutherford model of atom is also called nuclear model because it provides details about the nucleus of an atom.
The famous experiment called “Rutherford gold foil experiment” led to the discovery of the nucleus. In this experiment, alpha particles were bombarded through a gold foil; they were expected to go straight through the gold foil. But instead of straight penetration, alpha particles turned into different directions.
This indicated that there is something solid with a positive charge in that gold foil which causes a collision with alpha particles. Rutherford named this positive core as the nucleus. Then he suggested the nuclear model for the atom; it was composed of a positively charged nucleus and negatively charged electrons surrounding the nucleus. He also suggested that electrons are in orbitals around the nucleus in certain distances. This model is also called planetary model because Rutherford suggested that electrons are located around the nucleus similar to the planets located around the sun.
According to this model,
- The atom is composed of a positively charged center which is called the nucleus. This center contained the mass of the atom.
- Electrons are located outside the nucleus in orbitals in a considerable distance.
- The number of electrons is equal to the number of positive charges (later called protons) in the nucleus.
- The volume of the nucleus is negligible when compared to the volume of the atom. Hence, most of the space in the atom is empty.
However, this Rutherford model of atom was also rejected because it couldn’t explain why the electrons and the positive charges in the nucleus are not attracted to each other.
What is the difference between Thomson and Rutherford Model of Atom?
Thomson vs Rutherford Model of Atom
|Thomson model of atom is the model which states that electrons are embedded in a positively charged solid material which is spherical in shape.||Rutherford model of atom is the model which explains that there is a nucleus in the center of the atom and electrons are located around the nucleus.|
|Thomson model of atom does not give any detail about the nucleus.||Rutherford model of atom provides details about the nucleus of an atom and its location inside the atom.|
|Location of Electrons|
|According to Thomson model of atom, electrons are embedded in a solid material.||Rutherford model says electrons are located around the nucleus.|
|Thomson model of atom does not give details about orbitals.||Rutherford model of atom explains about orbitals and that electrons are located in these orbitals.|
|Thomson model of atom explains that the mass of an atom is the mass of positively charged solid where electrons are embedded.||According to the Rutherford model of atom, the mass of an atom is concentrated in the nucleus of the atom.|
Summary – Thomson vs Rutherford Models of Atom
Thomson and Rutherford models of atom were the earliest models to explain the structure of an atom. After the discovery of the electron by J.J. Thomson, he proposed a model to explain the structure of the atom. Later, Rutherford discovered the nucleus and introduced a new model using both electron and nucleus. The main difference between Thomson and Rutherford model of atom is that Thomson model of atom does not contain any details about nucleus whereas Rutherford model of atom explains about the nucleus of atom.
Download PDF Version of Thomson vs Rutherford Models of Atom
You can download PDF version of this article and use it for offline purposes as per citation notes. Please download PDF version here Difference Between Thomson and Rutherford Model of Atom.
1.”Rutherford Model of the Atom: Definition & Diagram.” Study.com. n.d. Web. Available here. 06 June 2017.
2. Brescia, Frank. Fundamentals of Chemistry: A Modern Introduction (1966). Elsevier, 2012. Print.
3. Goldsby, Kenneth. Chemistry. 12th ed. New York: McGraw-hill , 2015. Print.
1. “Plum pudding atom” ( Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia
2. “Rutherford atom”By Own work (CreateJODER Xd Xd) (CC BY-SA 3.0) via Commons Wikimedia
3. “Rutherford gold foil experiment results” By User: Fastfission Own work (Public Domain) via Commons Wikimedia
Leave a Reply