What is the Difference Between Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax

Pneumothorax and hydrothorax are two conditions that result from the accumulation or build-up of certain things in the pleural cavity. The pleural cavity is the space between the lungs and the chest wall, also known as the pleural space or intrapleural space. It has a small amount of serous fluid. The pleural cavity helps the lungs function optimally during breathing.

The key difference between pneumothorax and hydrothorax is their cause. Pneumothorax is a condition due to the presence of air in the pleural cavity while hydrothrorax is a condition due to fluid accumulation in the pleural cavity.

CONTENTS

1. Overview and Key Difference
2. What is Pneumothorax  
3. What is Hydrothorax
4. Similarities – Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax
5. Pneumothorax vs Hydrothorax in Tabular Form
6. Summary – Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax
7. FAQ – Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax

What is Pneumothorax?

Pneumothorax, also known as a collapsed lung, happens when there is air in the space between the chest wall and the lung or pleural cavity. The signs and symptoms of this condition are chest pain on one side, especially when breathing in, cough, fast breathing, fast heart rate, fatigue, shortness of breath, and cyanosis. It can be caused by medical conditions such as asthma, pneumonia, injuries like blunt force trauma, gunshot, stab wounds, lifestyle factors, drug use, and smoking.

Figure 01: Pneumothorax

Pneumothorax can be diagnosed through medical history, physical examination, chest X-ray, CT scan, and arterial blood gas test. Furthermore, treatment options for pneumothorax are oxygen therapy, thoracentesis, chest tube drainage, and chemical pleurodesis.

What is Hydrothorax?

Hydrothrorax, also known as pleural effusion, is due to fluid accumulating in the pleural cavity. It can be caused secondary to congestive heart failure, following an increase in hydrostatic pressure within the lungs or due to other medical conditions such as ascites. Moreover, the symptoms of hydrothorax may include breathing difficulties, chest pain, and coughing.

Figure 02: Hydrothorax

Hydrothorax can be diagnosed through a medical history review, physical examination, chest X-ray, CT scan, and thoracentesis. Furthermore, treatment options for hydrothorax include addressing the underlying cause and draining the accumulated fluid.

Similarities Between Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax

• Pneumothorax and hydrothorax are caused by problems in the pleural cavity.
• Both can cause difficulty in breathing and chest pain.
• Both can be diagnosed through physical examination and imaging tests.
• They can be treated by removing accumulated things and using supportive therapy.

Difference Between Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax

Definition

1. Pneumothorax is due to the build-up of air in the space between the chest wall and the lung.
2. Hydrothorax is due to the accumulation of fluid in the space between the chest wall and the lung.

Causes

1. Pneumothorax is caused by trauma, gunshot wounds, stabbing, drug use, and smoking.
2. Hydrothorax is caused secondary to congestive heart failure, an increase of hydrostatic pressure, and other medical conditions like ascites.

Signs and Symptoms

1. Pneumothorax is characterized by chest pain, difficulty in breathing, fast heart rate, fatigue, and bluish skin.
2. Hydrothorax is characterized by difficulty breathing, chest pain, and cough.

Diagnosis

1. Pneumothorax can be diagnosed by medical history, physical examination, imaging tests, and arterial blood gas tests.
   Hydrothorax can be diagnosed by medical history, physical examination, imaging tests, and thoracentesis.

Treatment

1. Pneumothorax can be treated by removing trapped air and surgical intervention.
2. Hydrothorax can be treated by managing the underlying condition and draining the fluid.

The following table summarizes the difference between pneumothorax and hydrothorax.

Summary – Pneumothorax vs Hydrothorax

The pleural cavity is the potential space between the pleurae of the pleural sac, which surrounds the lungs. It helps the breathing functions of the lungs. It also contains pleural fluid, which is a lubricant that allows the pleurae to slide effortlessly against each other during breathing. Pneumothorax and hydrothorax are two conditions that result from the accumulation of things in the pleural cavity. Pneumothorax is due to the build-up of air in the pleural cavity, while hydrothorax is due to the accumulation of fluid in the pleural cavity. This summarizes the difference between pneumothorax and hydrothorax.

FAQ: Pneumothorax and Hydrothorax

1. What is the main cause of pneumothorax?

• Pneumothorax is due to the air around or outside the lung or the build-up of air in the pleural cavity. It may result from chest trauma, excess pressure on the lungs, or other lung diseases.

2. Is a pneumothorax life-threatening?

• A pneumothorax can be severe depending on the amount of air that is trapped in the pleural space. A small amount of trapped air can usually resolve by itself. Larger amounts of trapped air can cause serious complications such as pulmonary edema, respiratory failure and heart failure.

3. How to fix a pneumothorax?

• Pneumothorax can be treated through a chest tube that will be placed between the ribs into the space around the lungs to help drain the air and allow the lung to re-expand, as well as other surgical interventions.

4. What causes a hydrothorax?

• The main cause of hydrothorax is cardiac failure. However, it frequently results from renal failure and cirrhosis of the liver, too. Other than that, it can also be caused by an increase in hydrostatic pressure and other medical conditions like ascites.

5. How is hydrothorax treated?

• Hydrothorax is treated with diuretics, a low-salt diet, repeated thoracentesis, pigtail drainage, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS), and surgery.

Reference:

1. “Pneumothorax (Collapsed Lung).” Cleveland Clinic.
2. “Hydrothorax – An Overview.” ScienceDirect Topics.

Image Courtesy:

1. “Lateral X-ray of pneumothorax in inspiration – annotated” By Mikael Häggström, M.D. – Own work (CC0) via Commons Wikimedia

2. “14-02-Erguss im Stehen” By Hellerhoff – Own work (CC BY-SA 3.0) via Commons Wikimedia

Related posts:

Difference Between Pandemic and Epidemic Difference Between Pubic Lice and Scabies Difference Between Physiological and Pathological Jaundice What is the Difference Between Gonococcal and Nongonococcal Urethritis What is the Difference Between Rosacea and Butterfly Rash