In today’s complex world, international relations and foreign policy have become vital concepts. They go beyond diplomatic actions; they are crucial for preventing conflicts and maintaining global peace. Understanding these concepts is essential for navigating the complexities of global politics and gaining insight into how nations interact and the challenges they face in pursuing international harmony.
The difference between international relations and foreign policy is their scope. International relations broadly cover relationships among various entities, while foreign policy focuses on interactions between sovereign states. Essentially, international relations offer a broad perspective on entity dynamics, while foreign policy delves into specific nation-to-nation relationships and strategies.
CONTENTS
1. Overview and Key Difference
2. What is International Relations
3. What is Foreign Policy
4. Similarities – International Relations and Foreign Policy
5. International Relations vs Foreign Policy in Tabular Form
6. Summary – International Relations vs Foreign Policy
7. FAQ – International Relations and Foreign Policy
What is International Relations?
The concept of international relations can be traced back to ancient times, with notable reflections by philosophers such as Thucydides in ancient Greece, who deliberated on the nature of peace and war. Concurrently, Asian philosophers like Thiruvalluvar contributed insights into diplomacy and the nature of the conflict. International relations as a field comprises broad sub-disciplines such as diplomacy, foreign policy, and international law. Closely interconnected disciplines like economics and political science also play important roles in shaping and understanding the dynamics of international relations.
Realism and conservatism are two critical concepts in the scope of international relations. These ideologies influence interactions among diverse actors on the global stage. International relations are characterized by the intricate interplay between various entities, with each actor contributing to the complex dynamics of diplomacy, foreign policy, and international law.
What is Foreign Policy?
Foreign policy is an important subdiscipline within international relations. It involves the interactions between sovereign states across various dimensions. This interaction involves the delicate balance of maintaining strong diplomacy and establishing bilateral agreements to foster economic cooperation. It also includes upholding the shared interests of citizens, reflecting the unique policy frameworks each uses to ensure the well-being of its people.
According to Keith R. Legg and James Morrison, foreign policy can be defined as “a set of explicit aims concerning the beyond the borders of a given social unit, along with a set of strategies and tactics crafted to achieve these objectives.” This definition highlights the deliberate and calculated nature of foreign policy, emphasizing its role in achieving predefined goals on the global stage. Adding depth to the discourse, Karl Marx posits that the foreign policy of a particular country is determined by the upper-class community within that nation. This perspective sheds light on the socioeconomic dynamics influencing the shaping of foreign policy, highlighting the role of the elite class in steering the course of international engagements. Apart from the scholarly perspectives on foreign policy, the foundation of a country’s foreign policy rests on protecting national interests and promoting national security.
Similarities Between International Relations and Foreign Policy
- Both international relations and foreign policy share the overarching goal of advancing national interests and ensuring security.
- Both international relations and foreign policy extend their purview to encompass relationships with both state and non-state actors.
- They involve analyzing the multifaceted dynamics between different nations and acknowledging the complexities that arise from their interactions on the global stage.
Differences Between International Relations and Foreign Policy
Definition
- International relations refers to the study of interactions between nations and other actors in the global arena, including states, international organizations, and non-state entities.
- Foreign policy refers to the strategies, decisions, and actions undertaken by a sovereign state to interact with other countries and international actors, aiming to safeguard national interests and promote national objectives.
Scope
- International relations involve the comprehensive study of relationships among countries, encompassing interactions between states, international organizations, and non-state actors.
- In contrast, foreign policy specifically pertains to relations between a particular country and others.
Nature
- Foreign policy is inherently goal-oriented, with a nation strategically pursuing specific objectives. These objectives may range from territorial expansion and economic development to ensuring the security of the state.
- In international relations, the focus extends beyond the limited official establishments involved in foreign policy. This field encompasses interactions among states, international organizations (such as WTO, WB, WNO), and non-state actors like NGOs. The absence of a singular goal related to limited official establishments allows for a more comprehensive examination of global dynamics.
Neutrality
- Foreign policy is inherently non-neutral, as it operates within a structured framework designed to serve the interests and well-being of a particular country.
- International relations emphasize neutrality among states and the pursuit of common interests. This approach fosters a broader understanding of the intricate network of global interactions while maintaining a stance of impartiality.
Below is a summary of the difference between international relations and foreign policy in tabular form for side by side comparison.
Summary – International Relations vs Foreign Policy
International relations and foreign policy are integral components of global politics, each with distinct scopes and emphases. International relations provide a broad perspective on the interactions among various entities, encompassing states, international organizations, and non-state actors. On the other hand, foreign policy specifically addresses a nation’s strategic goals and interactions with other sovereign entities. While both share the overarching goal of advancing national interests, foreign policy operates within a goal-oriented framework, while international relations embrace a more comprehensive examination of diverse actors and global dynamics. Understanding the difference between international relations and foreign policy is essential for navigating the complexities of the modern world and fostering international harmony.
FAQ: International Relations and Foreign Policy
1. How do international relations contribute to our understanding of global dynamics?
- Understanding the relationships among countries is not an easy task; often, countries have closed and opaque interactions with each other, primarily to promote their own interests. Hence, international relations offer various theories, such as realism and liberalism, to better understand global dynamics.
2. How does foreign policy address the shared interests of citizens in different countries?
- Every nation around the world has its own national interests, which sometimes align with those of other nations. For instance, in the 1970s, East Pakistan sought independence, leading to the creation of Bangladesh. India supported the East Pakistani Bengalis in this quest despite having no direct involvement, as it had approximately 10.42 crore Bengalis in West Bengal.
3. What role do non-state actors play in international relations, and how does it differ from foreign policy?
- Non-state actors play a significant role in maintaining peace and security among states. Entities such as the United Nations, the International Labour Organisation, and the International Monetary Fund contribute to shaping international relations. Unlike foreign policy, which is primarily the prerogative of states, non-state actors operate independently and often influence state behaviour through advocacy, diplomacy, and other means.
4. What does realism theory mean in international relations?
- Realism theory in international relations posits that states primarily prioritize their own national interests and power dynamics in their interactions with other states. E.H. Carr and Hans Morgenthau are among the main proponents of realism. According to realism, states are not bound by morality but rather act to maximize their own benefits and security.
5. What does “Cold War” mean?
- The Cold War refers to the ideological and geopolitical rivalry between two superpowers, namely the United States and the Soviet Union, during the aftermath of World War II. This conflict lasted from the late 1940s to the early 1990s. Notably, the Cold War did not involve direct military confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union but rather manifested through proxy wars, espionage, propaganda, and diplomatic standoffs.
Image Courtesy:
1. “Flags on Poles in Front of Building” (CC0) via Pexels
2. “21687086_1436127499808312_6352616378685047100_o – Two men shaking hands in front of flags” (Public Domain) via Picryl